Spin wheel vs scratch card: which mechanic should you pick?
Both are reveal mechanics with variable rewards. The capture rates are similar when both are designed well. The decision is about surface and ceremony, not capture math. Spin wheels work when the moment needs to feel public and dramatic — landing pages, sale events, shareable wins. Scratch cards work when the moment is private and instant — emails, push notifications, daily reveals. Most strong campaigns pick one based on where it lives, not which one has the higher conversion.
The 60-second answer
The fastest way to decide between spin and scratch
If you're choosing between these, the question isn't capture rate — both are similar when designed well. The question is where the campaign lives and how it should feel.
Key takeaways
Quick read- Spin and scratch are siblings — both are variable-reward reveal mechanics that capture emails as the price of claiming a prize.
- Spin wheels work better for landing pages, sale events, paid social, and any moment that benefits from drama and shareability. The wheel rotation is the share.
- Scratch cards work better for emails, push notifications, post-purchase modals, and daily-reveal cycles (advent calendars, daily rewards). The instant tap-to-reveal fits private moments.
- Capture rates are similar when both are designed well (25–50% on cold traffic, prize-revealed-first). The choice is surface fit, not conversion math.
- Default rule: pick spin if the campaign has a public face. Pick scratch if it lives in CRM, app, or post-purchase. When in doubt, the surface wins the argument.
The fundamental difference
What each one actually is, in one paragraph each
Both belong to the same mechanic family — variable-reward reveals — but the ceremony differs in ways that matter for surface fit, social proof, and repeat engagement.
Plain definition
A spin wheel is a circular variable-reward mechanic with 5–8 visible segments. The user taps to spin, the wheel rotates dramatically (2–4 seconds), and lands on a prize segment. The ceremony is public and dramatic — the rotation is visible, predictable in shape, and creates a moment that feels like a small live event. Common in landing pages, sale events, and paid-social-driven campaigns.
Who runs this
A scratch card is a hidden-reward mechanic where the prize is concealed under a layer the user reveals by tapping or scratching. The reveal is fast (under a second), private, and instant. The ceremony fits one-on-one moments — an email reveal, a push notification, a post-purchase modal. Common in CRM-led campaigns, daily-reveal cycles, and mobile-app activations.
How it differs from adjacent mechanics
- vs lottery and sweepstakes. Lotteries are time-bound, single-prize draws with explicit winners selected after a window. Spin and scratch are instant variable-reward mechanics; every participant gets a result immediately. Different operational model and different legal framing in many jurisdictions.
- vs instant-win promotions. Both spin and scratch are instant-win formats. The difference is the visual ceremony — a wheel rotates publicly, a scratch reveals privately. Same psychological pattern, different design.
- vs quizzes and product finders. Quizzes ask the user multiple questions and use the answers to deliver a personalised result. Spin and scratch are single-action mechanics — one tap, one prize. Quizzes fit acquisition; spin and scratch fit promotional moments.
- vs branded games. Branded games are entertainment-led (skill, time investment, multiple sessions). Spin and scratch are micro-mechanics — under 5 seconds from tap to claim. The shorter the action, the better the conversion.
Side by side
Eight dimensions where spin wheels and scratch cards differ
Pin this comparison to the brief. The decision usually clarifies once the team has agreed on surface, audience, and how the campaign should feel — public moment or private gift.
| Dimension | Spin wheel | Scratch card |
|---|---|---|
| Visual ceremony | Dramatic rotation · 2–4 seconds · public-feeling | Quiet reveal · under 1 second · private-feeling |
| Best surface | Landing pages, hero modules, sale-event microsites | Email, push, post-purchase modals, advent calendars |
| Social-share potential | High — the wheel rotation is the share | Low — the reveal is private and quiet |
| Mobile UX | Works at any screen size · animation-driven | Touch-driven · feels native on mobile, awkward on desktop |
| Audience expectation | “Win a prize” — competitive, dramatic | “Open a gift” — gentle, gift-like |
| Pacing across a campaign | One-shot drama · saturates after 1–2 attempts | Repeatable across days · works for daily cycles |
| Email capture rate (cold traffic) | 25–50% with reveal-first design | 25–50% with reveal-first design |
| Default brand fit | B2C consumer · sale-led, paid-social-driven | Premium, lifestyle, gifting-heavy categories |
Use a spin wheel when
The four conditions where spin is the right call
Spin wheels are public mechanics. They earn their keep when the campaign has a face — a landing page, a paid ad, a launch event. If the moment benefits from drama and shareability, spin is structurally the right answer.
Pick a spin wheel when the campaign has a public face.
The wheel rotation is half the value. It creates a small moment of suspense, a visible win, and (if the prize is good) something the user wants to share. Spin wheels concentrated on landing pages with hero space — that's where they pay back hardest.
today's drop
Use a scratch card when
The four conditions where scratch is the right call
Scratch cards are private mechanics. They earn their keep when the campaign lives inside a CRM channel — email, push, app — and the moment should feel personal, not theatrical.
Pick a scratch card when the campaign lives in CRM or app.
The scratch ceremony is fast, private, and feels like a small gift opening. That ceremony is exactly right for a one-to-one channel — email, push, post-purchase — where drama would feel out of place. Scratch cards earn their keep in the moments spin wheels can't reach.
When to combine them
The four patterns where running both works
Most campaigns pick one. But a handful of patterns benefit from running both — usually with the spin on the public face and the scratch in the CRM follow-up. Here are the four working combinations.
Spin on landing → scratch in welcome email
The wheel captures the email on the landing page. The first welcome email contains a scratch card revealing a second prize (samples, free shipping upgrade, or a referral bonus). The two mechanics work back-to-back: spin earns the email, scratch closes the second touchpoint. Capture-to-purchase conversion lifts noticeably vs single-mechanic flows.
Daily scratch advent calendar with a final-day spin
Days 1–6 are scratch reveals — one tap per day, small consistent prizes. Day 7 is a big spin event with a jackpot. The cadence fits the holiday gifting frame: small daily gifts building to the big finish. Quick commerce and beauty brands run this pattern around Diwali, Christmas, and major sale weeks.
Sale-event spin → post-spin scratch for the upsell
The user spins and wins a discount. Immediately after the win, a scratch card appears: “you also unlocked free shipping if you order today.” The scratch card is the upsell layer — a small additional incentive that doesn't compete with the wheel's main prize but lifts AOV in the same session.
Different audiences, different mechanics in the same campaign
Cold paid-social traffic gets the spin (drama, capture). Existing CRM list gets the scratch (private, gift-feeling). Both feed into the same offer pool, but the surface-appropriate mechanic carries the campaign on each channel. New-customer mix from spin is typically twice the new-customer mix from scratch in the same campaign.
Decision matrix
Which one to pick, in one scan
When you're stuck between the two, walk down this list. The first matching condition is usually the right answer.
| If your campaign... | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lives on a landing page with hero space | Spin wheel | The wheel's drama earns its keep on a public surface. Static signups in the same hero would cap at 15%. |
| Is delivered through email or push | Scratch card | Spin wheels feel dramatic and out of place in CRM. Scratch fits the private, one-to-one tone. |
| Needs to run for 7+ days as a daily cycle | Scratch card (advent format) | Daily reveals fit scratch's quick ceremony. Spin saturates after 1–2 attempts; scratch can repeat for weeks. |
| Has a public sale-event face (paid social, OOH, PR) | Spin wheel | The rotation is the marketing asset. Jackpot wins generate user-generated content; scratch reveals don't share publicly. |
| Lives inside an app or post-purchase modal | Scratch card | Spin wheels in-app feel disruptive. Scratch reveals feel earned and contained. |
| Brand voice is premium, lifestyle, or gifting-led | Scratch card | Wheels read as cheap to premium audiences. Scratch reveals read as gifts and preserve brand tone. |
| Brand voice is consumer-led, fast, and energetic | Spin wheel | Drama fits the brand. The wheel becomes a campaign icon for the next cycle. |
| Needs to A/B test prize structures publicly | Spin wheel | Visible segments make the prize mix transparent and testable. Scratch hides the mix. |
What to expect when you pick right
Three signals that the mechanic-surface fit is working
When you match the mechanic to the surface, three numbers tell you whether the campaign is healthy. These are the operating ranges that working spin and scratch campaigns hit.
Common mistakes
The four ways teams pick the wrong mechanic
Wrong-mechanic-on-wrong-surface is the most common cause of underperforming reveal campaigns. Here are the four specific mismatches to watch for.
- Putting a spin wheel inside an emailEmail opens happen in 30–60 seconds. The wheel's 4-second rotation feels long and out of place; users skip the animation or close the email before it finishes. Replace with a scratch card — the same mechanic family, with a ceremony that fits the channel.
- Putting a scratch card on a paid-traffic landing pageCold paid traffic needs drama to commit. A static-feeling scratch card converts noticeably worse than a wheel on the same hero. The wheel's rotation is half the persuasion; without it, capture rate drops 30–40% on paid surfaces.
- Running a 14-day spin sale with one spin per dayDaily-reset spin sounds clever but the drama saturates fast. By day 4, users skip the animation and just claim. Replace with daily scratch (or use the spin once on day 1 and scratch days 2–14). Daily-reveal cadences fit scratch's ceremony, not spin's.
- Asking for the email before the revealTrue for both mechanics: gating the email before the wheel spins or before the scratch reveals halves capture rate. Reveal-first is the working pattern. The mechanic is the value; the email is what the user pays for it. Email-first design is the most common reason both mechanics underperform.
Frequently asked
The questions teams ask before they ship either
Q01Which has higher email capture — spin wheels or scratch cards?
When both are designed correctly (reveal-first, prize visible before the email step), they capture at similar rates: 25–50% on cold traffic. When designed incorrectly (email-first gate), both drop to 10–15%. The mechanic isn't the variable; the design is. Choose based on surface fit, not capture math.
Q02Are scratch cards considered gambling? What about spin wheels?
Both are typically classified as ‘promotional sweepstakes’ rather than gambling, because participants don't pay to play. The legal framing varies by jurisdiction — some markets require explicit terms (no purchase necessary, total prize pool, odds disclosure). Both mechanics carry similar legal weight; check local sweepstakes regulations before launch in regulated markets.
Q03Can I run both in the same campaign?
Yes, and it often works well. The most common pattern: spin wheel on the landing page (cold traffic capture), scratch card in the welcome email (CRM follow-up). The two mechanics work back-to-back rather than competing for attention. Combined campaigns typically lift end-to-end conversion 15–30% over single-mechanic flows.
Q04What's the right number of segments on a spin wheel?
Five to eight segments is the working range. Below five, the wheel feels barren and the prize odds become too obvious. Above eight, segments are too small to read on mobile and the rotation feels random rather than dramatic. Six segments with one jackpot, two mid-prizes, and three guaranteed wins is the modal answer.
Q05How many scratch reveals should be in an advent calendar campaign?
Seven days is the most-used length (week-long advent). Fourteen days is the maximum that holds attention. Above 14 days, daily participation drops as the novelty wears off. Run the campaign with one reveal per day; on the final day, layer a bigger reveal (often a spin or a jackpot scratch) for the campaign's climax.
Q06What prizes should a spin wheel offer vs a scratch card?
Both work best with the same shape: 4–5 small guaranteed wins (free shipping, 5% off, sample), 1–2 mid-tier prizes (10% off, premium sample), 1 rare jackpot (20% off, exclusive product, gift box). The prize structure is mechanic-agnostic; what differs is how the prize is framed in the post-reveal moment.
Q07Should I show the prize odds to the user?
For spin wheels, often yes — visible odds (‘1 in 50 spins win the jackpot’) increases trust and reduces dispute volume. For scratch cards, less often — the scratch ceremony is gift-like and showing odds breaks the framing. The general rule: spin is competitive (show odds), scratch is gift-like (frame as luck).
Q08Which mechanic works better for B2B?
Neither, generally. Both spin and scratch read as consumer-promotional and feel out of place in B2B audiences. B2B teams looking for variable-reward mechanics usually do better with quizzes (more thoughtful, content-led) or gated downloads with surprise unlocks. Spin and scratch are best for consumer brands, especially in retail, beauty, food, and entertainment categories.
Ship the spin or the scratch — or both — without a code review
Configure either mechanic in one place. Same builder, same liability cap, same analytics. Live the same week.
Ready to ship?
Try Bricqs free, or talk to a strategist
Plan a campaign, configure the engine, and ship in days. No credit card required to start.